Summary

Introduction

This report summarizes the results of public input, encompassing:

60 statements
60 votes
7 topics
28 subtopics

All voters were anonymous.

Overview

Below is a high level overview of the topics discussed in the conversation, as well as the percentage of statements categorized under each topic. Note that the percentages may add up to greater than 100% when statements fall under more than one topic.

Essential Services & Community Infrastructure (33%): Statements proposed enhancing essential services and community infrastructure through physical and digital modernization. The conversation highlighted initiatives to create affordable housing, develop multi-purpose community hubs, and establish sustainable transportation networks to strengthen the local economy and address service shortages.
Community Facility Development & Refurbishment (32%): The conversation detailed extensive development and refurbishment of community facilities to address structural deterioration and a lack of adequate spaces. Statements outlined essential repairs, modernization for accessibility, and sustainability upgrades to secure the future of these buildings as central hubs that foster social connection and well-being.
Health & Wellbeing Services (22%): Statements on this topic centered on combating social isolation and improving mental health through accessible, community-led initiatives. The conversation included proposals to create and maintain local hubs that provide targeted support for vulnerable groups and use community facilities to overcome barriers to healthcare access.
Heritage Preservation & Cultural Events (18%): The conversation focused on restoring and repurposing historic structures for new public functions and supporting inclusive community festivals. Statements presented these initiatives as a way to drive economic revitalization and strengthen social cohesion by addressing urgent repairs and improving visitor access.
Environmental Sustainability & Green Initiatives (17%): Statements centered on developing new infrastructure and transforming land use to meet climate goals, with initiatives aiming to increase local food and energy production, establish circular economy systems, and encourage active travel. A prominent theme was the integration of these environmental objectives with socio-economic benefits like job creation and community well-being.
Youth Services & Skills Development (15%): The conversation centered on creating opportunities and support systems for young people through direct engagement in community planning and skills training programs tailored to local economic needs. Statements also emphasized establishing safe, inclusive spaces and targeted services to combat social isolation and support vulnerable youth and their families.
Sports, Recreation & Play (12%): Statements on this topic centered on enhancing community infrastructure for sports, recreation, and play by creating new facilities and upgrading existing assets to improve safety and accessibility. These community-led initiatives seek to promote physical and mental well-being and foster social cohesion for both residents and tourists.

Top 5 Most Discussed Subtopics

28 subtopics of discussion emerged. These 5 subtopics had the most statements submitted.

1. Digital & Communications Infrastructure (10 statements)

Prominent themes were:

Improving digital access and services
Enhancing community infrastructure and facilities
Supporting tourism and the visitor experience
Fostering community connection and communication
Increasing accessibility for residents and visitors

2. Internal Refurbishment & Modernization (10 statements)

Prominent themes were:

Addressing structural repairs and safety
Modernizing facilities and improving accessibility
Enhancing spaces for community use and services
Improving energy efficiency and sustainability
Ensuring long-term viability and resilience

3. Energy Efficiency & Sustainability Upgrades (9 statements)

Prominent themes were:

Improving energy efficiency and reducing running costs
Upgrading and repairing building infrastructure
Enhancing vital community spaces and services
Ensuring long-term sustainability and resilience
Integrating renewable energy sources

4. Mental Health & Social Inclusion (9 statements)

Prominent themes were:

Reducing social isolation and fostering connection
Creating safe and inclusive community hubs
Supporting mental health and emotional wellbeing
Improving access to support and activities
Enabling peer support and skill sharing

5. Community Wellbeing Initiatives (8 statements)

Prominent themes were:

Reducing social isolation and loneliness
Creating and improving shared community spaces
Promoting mental and physical wellbeing
Easing cost of living and financial barriers
Increasing access to local services and activities

Topics

From the statements submitted, 7 high level topics were identified, as well as 28 subtopics. Based on voting patterns both points of common ground as well as differences of opinion have been identified and are described below.

Essential Services & Community Infrastructure (20 statements)

This topic included 5 subtopics, comprising a total of 20 statements.

Digital & Communications Infrastructure (10 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Digital Modernization Of Community Services: Statements propose creating new websites with features like click-and-collect platforms and online membership systems to improve the accessibility and efficiency of community-led services.
Infrastructure For Tourism And Visitor Management: Proposals include installing digital signage with QR codes, interactive information boards, and EV charging points to improve the visitor experience, manage access, and support the local economy.
Improving Community Communication And Cohesion: Some statements aim to improve information sharing among residents and organizations through redesigned websites, video conferencing facilities, and, in one case, a dual approach using both digital and physical noticeboards to ensure inclusivity.
Developing Digital Hubs And Skills: Certain proposals seek to establish dedicated ICT hubs with modern equipment and provide digital training for staff, volunteers, and community members to build digital literacy and confidence.
Establishing Foundational Infrastructure For Future Needs: Statements identify a need to install fundamental infrastructure, such as electricity connections for EV chargers or wiring for ICT hubs, to support the transition to new technologies and enable modern community functions.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Differences of opinion: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a significant difference of opinion (at least 20 votes, and both an agreement rate and disagree rate between 40%% and 60%%).

Transportation & Connectivity (7 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Active Travel Infrastructure: Several statements propose creating safe pathways for walking and cycling to connect communities, reduce car dependency, and improve public safety.
Accessible Transport For Vulnerable Groups: One statement highlights a need for dedicated, accessible vehicles to transport elderly and disabled residents to essential services, noting that existing public transport is inadequate for their needs.
Visitor-Facing Infrastructure And Management: Some statements focus on upgrading facilities for tourists, including improving ferry gateways, installing visitor signage, and creating amenities to manage visitor flows and enhance their experience.
Transition To Greener Transportation: Statements describe a desire to support environmentally friendly transport by installing infrastructure for electric vehicles and creating networks that encourage walking and cycling to reduce carbon footprints.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Local Economic & Skills Development (5 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Addressing Local Housing Shortages: Several statements propose creating new affordable housing or refurbishing existing properties to address critical shortages, particularly for local residents.
Creating Employment and Skills Training: The statements describe initiatives aimed at generating local employment and providing skills training, including in heritage construction, quarrying, and through volunteering as a pathway to work.
Utilizing Local Heritage and Natural Assets: Proposals frequently aim to leverage unique local resources for economic and social benefit, such as reviving a historic quarry, restoring heritage buildings, and redeveloping community-owned forest land.
Community-Led Development and Capacity Building: Projects are driven by community trusts and local groups, with some statements identifying the need for dedicated staff like a development officer or volunteer coordinator to enable the delivery of community plans.
Focus on Long-Term Sustainability: The proposals often emphasize long-term viability through multi-decade project lifespans, circular economy principles, renewable energy, and the preservation of buildings and skills for the future.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Community Hubs & Public Spaces (5 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Upgrading and Developing Physical Infrastructure: Statements propose projects that range from repairing dilapidated buildings and upgrading existing halls to creating entirely new, multi-purpose community sites with housing, gardens, and trails.
Enhancing Social Cohesion and Well-being: The proposals are presented as a way to strengthen community bonds by providing dedicated spaces for social interaction, events, and activities that address issues such as social isolation.
Providing Economic, Practical, and Resilience Benefits: Several statements describe how projects will support local economies through tourism, create employment, offer practical solutions like affordable housing, and enhance community resilience with facilities like emergency power generators.
Addressing Deficiencies in Local Services and Infrastructure: Proposals are justified by the need to remedy existing problems, such as neglected buildings, the loss of former community assets, or a general lack of adequate facilities and services for residents and visitors.
Catering to a Broad Range of Community Activities and Demographics: The statements outline plans for multi-purpose spaces intended to serve diverse groups—including youth, the elderly, families, and visitors—through a wide variety of activities like sports, arts, education, and support services.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Affordable & Community Housing (2 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Addressing Housing Scarcity: Both statements identify a critical shortage of affordable housing on their respective islands and propose projects to create more housing for local residents.
Integration with Broader Community Goals: The statements present housing as part of larger projects that include amenities like community gardens, forests, and social spaces to enhance community life and create destinations.
Development Approaches Emphasizing Environment or Heritage: The proposals approach development with specific considerations, with one statement detailing an environmentally sustainable new build and the other focusing on the specialist refurbishment required to preserve A-listed heritage buildings.
Creation of Local Employment and Training: Both statements connect their housing projects to the creation of local employment and skills development opportunities, including training for young people and in specialized trades.
Long-Term Vision and Legacy: The statements frame their projects as having a long-term impact, describing them as legacy initiatives that will provide lasting benefits and be preserved for the future community.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Community Facility Development & Refurbishment (19 statements)

This topic included 4 subtopics, comprising a total of 19 statements.

Internal Refurbishment & Modernization (10 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Repair Of Aging And Deficient Infrastructure: Several statements identify the need to conduct essential repairs to address structural deterioration, water ingress, and outdated or non-functional systems and equipment in existing community buildings.
Strengthening Buildings As Central Community Hubs: The statements propose refurbishments to enhance or create central community hubs that host a wide range of social, cultural, and recreational activities intended to combat isolation and foster social connection.
Improving Service Delivery And Accessibility: Many statements describe how refurbishments will improve the delivery of essential services, such as health clinics, support for vulnerable populations, and digital access, as well as enhance physical accessibility.
Promoting Long-Term Sustainability And Resilience: Some statements link building modernization to long-term viability by improving energy efficiency, supporting the circular economy, creating employment, and establishing facilities to serve as resilience hubs during emergencies.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Energy Efficiency & Sustainability Upgrades (9 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Improving Energy Efficiency to Reduce Costs: Statements describe upgrades like insulation, efficient heating systems, and modern windows to lower operational expenses and ensure the financial sustainability of community facilities.
Modernization and Structural Repair of Aging Facilities: Many proposals focus on refurbishing or repairing aging community buildings to address issues like water ingress, structural deterioration, and outdated equipment.
Enhancing Community Hubs and Services: The proposed upgrades are frequently justified as necessary to maintain or enhance vital community spaces that provide social, health, recreational, and emergency services.
Adoption of Renewable Energy Sources: Some statements propose installing or upgrading renewable energy systems, such as solar panels and biomass boilers, to generate power and heat sustainably.
Alignment with Broader Environmental Goals: Several statements explicitly frame their projects as contributing to wider objectives such as achieving Net Zero, reducing environmental impact, and addressing the climate emergency.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

New Construction & Facility Expansion (6 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Addressing a Lack of Suitable Facilities: The statements propose new construction or expansion to address situations where facilities are described as non-existent, inadequate, in poor condition, or too small for community demand.
Focus on Community Well-being: The proposed facilities are presented as a way to enhance residents' physical and mental health, provide social and recreational opportunities, and reduce issues like isolation.
Necessity of Localized Services: Several statements emphasize that new facilities must be provided locally due to geographic isolation, such as being on an island or in a rural area, which restricts access to services elsewhere.
Wider Community and Environmental Impact: Statements describe the projects as generating broader benefits, such as promoting environmental goals like reuse and waste reduction, supporting the local economy, and helping to retain or attract residents.
Advanced State of Project Planning: The proposals are frequently presented as being well-developed, with statements citing completed community consultations, secured planning permissions, existing equipment, or the successful completion of previous project stages.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Structural Repairs & Weatherproofing (6 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Addressing Water Ingress and Weather Damage: Several statements identify an urgent need to make buildings wind and watertight by repairing failing roofs, leaking skylights, and damaged exteriors to stop water ingress and prevent further deterioration.
Improving Energy Efficiency and Sustainability: Some statements propose upgrades such as new insulation, modern solar panels, and efficient heating systems to reduce long-term operational costs and contribute to environmental goals like low-carbon energy use or Net Zero.
Preserving Heritage Buildings: A number of proposals concern the repair of historically significant structures, including A and B listed buildings and former churches, with some specifying the need for specialist conservation work to protect their architectural heritage.
Ensuring Viability for Community Use: The proposed repairs are consistently presented as essential for making community facilities safe, functional, and comfortable, thereby securing their future as hubs for social, cultural, health, and recreational activities.
Rectifying Structural Deficiencies: Statements describe buildings as being in poor structural condition or dangerous disrepair, necessitating foundational work on elements like roofs, walls, and floors to ensure the structures are sound and safe for public use.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Health & Wellbeing Services (13 statements)

This topic included 4 subtopics, comprising a total of 13 statements.

Mental Health & Social Inclusion (9 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Addressing Social Isolation: The statements frequently identify social isolation as a critical issue affecting diverse groups, including the elderly, bereaved families, rural residents, and individuals with mental health conditions, proposing projects to foster connection.
Creation of Community Hubs: Several statements propose creating new or renovating existing physical spaces, such as sheds, inns, and halls, to serve as central, accessible locations for social activities and support services.
Targeted and Inclusive Support: Many proposals focus on providing tailored support and inclusive activities for specific populations, such as bereaved families, neurodivergent individuals, people with poor mental health, and families of children with additional support needs.
Improving Mental and Emotional Wellbeing: A central goal across the statements is to improve mental and emotional wellbeing through various means, including peer support, recreational and creative activities, respite, and providing safe, stigma-free environments.
Removing Barriers to Participation: The statements emphasize making services more accessible by addressing financial barriers through low-cost or free offerings, overcoming geographical isolation in rural areas, and providing dedicated support for those facing specific challenges.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Community Wellbeing Initiatives (8 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Creation and Upkeep of Community Venues: Many proposals focus on the physical infrastructure of community life, involving the creation of new facilities like workshops and gardens or the essential repair and refurbishment of existing village halls and community buildings.
Combating Social Isolation: Multiple statements propose creating or improving shared spaces and activities to combat social isolation and loneliness, particularly for older residents or in communities that have lost social hubs.
Promotion of Health, Wellbeing, and Skills: A recurring goal is to improve residents' physical and mental wellbeing through activities, enhanced access to health services, and opportunities to learn and share practical skills.
Addressing Geographic Isolation and Service Gaps: Several statements highlight the challenges of being in a rural or remote location, proposing projects that provide essential local services and hubs to reduce residents' need to travel.
Response to Economic Pressures: Some statements frame their projects as a response to the cost of living crisis by aiming to remove financial barriers and provide access to low-cost or free services, activities, and warm spaces.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Specialized Support Services (4 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Focus on Vulnerable and Specialized Groups: The statements describe services tailored for specific populations such as neurodivergent individuals, bereaved families, adults with poor mental health, and children with additional support needs.
Emphasis on Mental Wellbeing and Social Connection: A primary goal cited across the statements is to improve mental and emotional health and reduce social isolation for service users and their families.
Provision of Services to Address Unmet Needs: Several statements highlight that their services fill a critical gap, either by being the only available option in an area, by meeting overwhelming demand, or by reducing pressure on statutory services.
Community-Led and Collaborative Approaches: The services are described as being community-led, parent-led, or operating through partnerships with other local organizations, businesses, and health services to deliver support.
Need for Funding to Ensure Service Continuity and Stability: All statements are requests for funding to continue, sustain, or expand existing services, ensuring their long-term stability and ability to meet community demand.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Access to Healthcare & Medical Services (3 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Geographic Barriers to Access: Statements describe how remote rural locations, limited public transport, and significant travel distances create major obstacles for residents trying to access medical services.
Role of Community Hubs in Health Delivery: The statements propose using and upgrading community-run assets, such as village halls and transport services, to provide local venues for health clinics or to connect residents to distant medical appointments.
Impact of Service Centralization: Some statements note that medical services are being moved out of local areas and centralized in larger, more distant hospitals, which increases travel burdens for patients.
Infrastructure Condition as a Limiting Factor: The viability of providing local health services is linked in the statements to the physical condition of community infrastructure, with deteriorating buildings and a lack of accessible vehicles cited as direct impediments.
Focus on Vulnerable Populations: The proposals emphasize the particular difficulties faced by aging populations, people with disabilities, and those with mobility challenges in overcoming barriers to healthcare.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Heritage Preservation & Cultural Events (11 statements)

This topic included 3 subtopics, comprising a total of 11 statements.

Historic Site & Building Restoration (7 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Economic and Demographic Revitalization: Statements present restoration projects as a means to address wider socio-economic challenges by creating jobs, providing affordable housing, and counteracting rural depopulation.
Urgent Structural Preservation: Many statements emphasize the need to address physical deterioration—such as water damage from failing roofs, crumbling masonry, and environmental threats—to halt the decay of historic structures.
Enhancing Community and Visitor Functions: Projects are frequently intended to restore or create functional spaces for community life, including social hubs, cultural events, visitor centers, and educational engagement.
Ensuring Long-Term Viability: Several statements outline plans to make the restored sites sustainable through revenue generation for reinvestment, local skills training for ongoing maintenance, and energy efficiency improvements.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Heritage Interpretation & Access (3 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Restoration and Adaptation of Historic Structures: Statements describe projects to physically restore and repurpose A-listed heritage buildings to make them weatherproof, structurally sound, and suitable for new uses like exhibitions, visitor centers, and accommodation.
Improving Visitor Access and Interpretation: The proposals aim to enhance the visitor experience by reopening sites, creating designated walking routes, and providing better interpretation through exhibitions, information points, signage, and self-guided tours.
Fostering Community and Economic Benefits: The projects are presented as a means to generate local benefits by involving the community in heritage storytelling, creating employment and volunteer opportunities, and developing facilities to support the local economy.
Integration of Digital Tools: Some statements propose using digital technologies, including audio-visual elements, QR codes, and potential mobile apps, to enrich site interpretation and guide visitors.
Balancing Access with Local Interests: The statements address the need to manage visitor access in consideration of local concerns, such as liaising with landowners about walkers on farmland and adapting historic buildings to be energy efficient.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Cultural Festivals & Events (3 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Accessibility and Inclusivity: The statements describe efforts to make cultural events accessible through low-cost or free pricing, providing transportation, and creating inclusive programming for diverse groups, including neurodivergent audiences and local community organizations.
Community Cohesion and Social Benefits: Statements highlight that these events foster community connection through volunteerism and participation, promote social inclusion and local pride, and contribute to mental well-being.
Operational Viability and Funding: The proposals outline specific funding needs for operational costs, such as securing artists and speakers, providing transportation services, and covering general running expenses for a set period.
Economic Impact and Tourism: One statement explicitly details how a festival can attract tourism, benefit local businesses, and serve as a promotional tool for the wider region.
Providing a Platform for Arts and Culture: The proposals aim to sustain and grow platforms for specific art forms, including cinema, literature, and music, by offering diverse programming and creating opportunities for artists to showcase their work.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Environmental Sustainability & Green Initiatives (10 statements)

This topic included 5 subtopics, comprising a total of 10 statements.

Community Gardens & Local Food Production (3 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Community Engagement and Well-Being: The statements present these projects as creating spaces that foster social interaction, provide educational and recreational resources, and enhance the overall well-being of residents.
Local Food Production and Supply: The proposals aim to increase local food production through gardens, allotments, and orchards, with some statements noting goals to reduce food miles and supply community-owned businesses.
Environmental and Sustainability Goals: The projects are framed as contributing to environmental objectives, which include promoting ecological practices, increasing biodiversity, capturing carbon, and supporting island-wide carbon neutral plans.
Infrastructure and Economic Development: The statements describe the development of physical infrastructure, ranging from garden structures to housing and energy systems, which in turn are linked to creating employment and other economic benefits.
Land Use and Restoration: The proposals involve transforming land, such as a derelict site or a commercial plantation, into multi-purpose community assets that also serve ecological functions.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Waste Reduction & Circular Economy (3 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Circular Economy and Resource Management: The statements propose projects that keep resources in use, such as reusing furniture, creating a local fuel supply from waste wood, and seeking ways to manage marine litter instead of landfilling it.
Community and Social Benefits: The proposals are presented as having significant social benefits, including providing affordable housing and fuel, creating jobs, supporting people in crisis, and developing community spaces like gardens and improved shorelines.
Environmental Improvement Beyond Waste Reduction: Statements describe projects aimed at improving the local environment through methods such as reducing landfill emissions, tackling marine plastic pollution, and restoring native forests for carbon capture and biodiversity.
Need for New Infrastructure and Technology: The statements identify a need for new physical infrastructure and technology, including expanded reuse facilities with new capabilities, an innovative solution for separating marine litter, and a district heating system using local resources.
Collaborative and Cross-Sector Partnerships: The proposals emphasize a collaborative approach, detailing existing and planned partnerships with government bodies, educational institutions, private sector entities, and other third-sector organizations to achieve project goals.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Active & Green Travel (3 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Infrastructure For Green Travel: Statements propose the creation of new infrastructure, such as an EV charge point and safe walking/wheeling paths, to support alternative modes of transportation.
Contribution To Environmental Goals: The proposals are presented as a way to help achieve environmental objectives, including reducing the carbon footprint and supporting the transition to Net Zero.
Public Safety Concerns: The statements advocating for paths identify current roads as unsafe for walkers and cyclists, framing the new infrastructure as a necessary safety improvement.
Economic And Community Benefits: Some statements suggest the projects will benefit the local economy by supporting businesses, attracting visitors, and generating revenue for community initiatives.
Shifting Transportation Habits: The statements aim to reduce dependency on conventional car use by either facilitating a switch to electric vehicles or creating safe routes to encourage walking and cycling.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Conservation & Biodiversity (2 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Habitat Restoration and Management: The statements propose actions such as replanting a commercial plantation with native broadleaf trees and controlling an invasive plant species.
Integrating Community and Socio-Economic Needs: One statement details a project that combines environmental restoration with solutions for community challenges, including affordable housing, employment, and local fuel production.
Creation of Community Spaces: A statement describes a project intended to create community-focused areas such as a garden, orchard, allotments, and forest trails for public enjoyment and group use.
Incorporating Climate and Energy Solutions: One statement outlines a project that includes carbon capture through tree planting and on-site renewable energy generation through a wind turbine, solar panels, and a district heating system.
Management of Specific Plant Species: The statements focus on specific flora, proposing the replacement of commercial Sitka Spruce with native trees and the control of invasive Japanese Knotweed.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Renewable Energy & Energy Efficiency (2 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

On-Site Renewable Energy Generation: Statements describe plans to generate renewable energy through the installation or upgrading of technologies like solar panels, wind turbines, and biomass heating systems.
Aspiration For Carbon Neutrality And Net Zero: Both statements frame their projects as significant steps toward achieving ambitious environmental targets, specifically mentioning goals of becoming Carbon Neutral or Net Zero.
Infrastructure And Building Efficiency: The statements propose improving energy efficiency through physical infrastructure upgrades, such as installing new roofs with better insulation and implementing district heating systems to reduce heat loss.
Integration With Community And Economic Goals: The energy projects are presented as integral components of larger initiatives aimed at delivering wider socio-economic benefits, such as affordable housing, employment, and securing the viability of community facilities.
Sustainable Resource Management: Statements detail approaches to managing resources sustainably, including creating a circular economy for local fuelwood and reducing energy waste through improved building performance.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Youth Services & Skills Development (9 statements)

This topic included 4 subtopics, comprising a total of 9 statements.

Youth Engagement & Civic Participation (5 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Methodology of Youth Consultation: All statements detail projects where S3 Geography students used structured methods, such as the Place Standard Tool and site-specific surveys, to assess and provide feedback on their local communities.
Commonly Identified Positive Attributes: Across several locations, students identified "Feeling Safe," "Moving Around," and "Natural Space" as positive characteristics of their communities.
Recurring Areas for Improvement: Multiple statements highlight students' desire for improvements in "Play and Recreation," "Facilities and Services," and "Traffic and Parking," with some also noting "Work and local economy."
Location-Specific Priorities: The specific strengths and weaknesses identified by students varied between different towns and, as noted in the Oban statement, even within different parts of a single catchment area.
Divergent Views on Specific Features: The statements reveal differing assessments on the same community features across locations, as seen with public transport being viewed positively in Rothesay but as needing improvement in the Oban islands.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Skills Training & Employability (2 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Targeted Skills for Local Needs: The statements propose skills training programs tailored to specific local needs, such as heritage building maintenance in one case and digital literacy in the other.
Focus on Underserved Populations: The statements identify specific underserved or disadvantaged groups within their communities, such as local youth and adults excluded from the digital economy, as the primary beneficiaries of the training initiatives.
Linking Training to Employment: Both proposals emphasize that the purpose of the skills training is to create direct pathways to employment, career opportunities, and economic advancement for participants.
Provision of Holistic Support: In addition to technical instruction, the proposals describe providing wider support systems, including access to equipment, mentoring, and addressing fundamental needs like housing.
Emphasis on Long-Term Community Impact: Both statements frame their projects as investments with long-term community benefits, focusing on sustainability through local skill-building, heritage preservation, or plans for future scaling.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Youth Clubs & Positive Activities (2 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Creation of Safe and Inclusive Environments: The statements describe the clubs as providing safe and inclusive spaces where children can build connections and participate in activities.
Focus on Specific Youth Populations: The statements indicate the clubs are designed to serve particular groups, including youth in rural areas, those from families in difficulty, and children with additional support needs (ASN).
Mitigation of Social Isolation: Both statements present the clubs as a way to reduce social isolation, specifically for young people on Islay and for parents of children with additional support needs.
Provision of Support for Families: The statements note that the clubs offer support that extends to the participants' families, such as helping to reduce poverty-related barriers and providing informal emotional support for parents.
Offering Tailored Activities and Resources: The statements detail the provision of specific activities and resources, such as skills development, sensory play, and quiet spaces, which are designed to meet the needs of the children they serve.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Targeted Support for Vulnerable Youth (2 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Creation of Safe and Inclusive Environments: Both statements describe their projects as providing safe and inclusive spaces where vulnerable young people can feel a sense of belonging.
Focus on Specific Vulnerable Groups: The statements identify distinct target populations, with one focusing on youth experiencing rural poverty and marginalization and the other on children with additional support needs (ASN).
Support for Parents and Families: The statements describe support that extends beyond the children to their families and carers, including breaking parental isolation and helping families overcome barriers.
Provision of Specialized Activities: Both statements detail offering a range of activities, such as arts, crafts, sensory play, and skills development, which are tailored to the specific needs of the youth they serve.
Combating Social Isolation: A shared goal in the statements is to reduce social isolation by helping young people and their parents build meaningful connections and community.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Sports, Recreation & Play (7 statements)

This topic included 3 subtopics, comprising a total of 7 statements.

Sports Pitches, Courts & Greens (4 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Need for Weather-Proof or Accessible Facilities: Statements justify the projects by citing the negative impact of changing weather on outdoor activities, the complete lack of suitable local spaces, or the geographic isolation of island communities.
Community Health and Social Cohesion: The proposals are described as essential for improving community well-being, aiming to increase sports participation, provide social opportunities, and help retain families and young people.
Maintenance and Upgrading of Existing Assets: Some statements focus on the need to repair and improve existing bowling greens to address degradation from weather and use, ensure player safety, and meet official standards.
Inclusivity and Broadened Sporting Opportunities: Projects aim to make sports more accessible for various groups, such as the elderly and wheelchair users, and to enable a wider range of sports to be played locally for the first time.
Volunteer Involvement and Project Delivery: Several statements note that project execution will involve community volunteers to reduce costs and learn new skills, or that the proposed facilities will be managed through community partnerships.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Play Parks & Wheeled Sports Areas (2 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Enhancement of Local Infrastructure and Facilities: The statements propose creating new infrastructure like a pump track and enhancing existing community facilities with items such as playground equipment, a bike pump, and visitor signage.
Provision of Safe Recreational Spaces: One statement proposes a pump track as a safe, enclosed area for children to ride bikes away from a fast and dangerous road.
Fostering Community and Social Interaction: The statements describe the proposed facilities as community hubs that can reduce social isolation, bring different generations together, and make the areas more community-oriented.
Promotion of Health and Well-being: One statement highlights that a pump track would provide physical exercise, improve mental well-being, and encourage outdoor activity away from screens.
Support for Both Residents and Visitors: The proposals aim to improve amenities for the local community, with one statement also specifically mentioning the need to better support visitors by improving infrastructure and managing issues like overcrowding.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).

Community Gardens & Recreational Amenities (2 statements)

This subtopic had high alignment compared to the other subtopics.

Prominent themes were:

Enhancement of Community Infrastructure and Equipment: Statements propose adding or upgrading physical assets such as a Polycrub for a community garden, playground equipment, public shelters, and shared community resources.
Promotion of Community Well-being and Recreation: Proposals aim to improve quality of life by providing new educational and recreational resources, including facilities for all-year gardening and community events.
Support for Both Residents and Visitors: The projects are described as benefiting the local population and, in one case, specifically aim to better manage visitor flows and improve the tourist experience through enhanced amenities and information.
Generation of Practical and Sustainable Benefits: The proposals are expected to yield tangible outcomes, including the local production of food, a reduction in council maintenance, and the long-term use of durable, community-owned assets.
Emphasis on Community-Led Planning: The projects are presented as originating from community-identified needs, with one statement explicitly citing a Community Action Plan and planned collaboration among various local organizations.

Common ground: No statements met the thresholds necessary to be considered as a point of common ground (at least 20 votes, and at least 70% agreement).